Industry news

Digital Fairness Act: the Commission's proposal on dark patterns and subscriptions

The European proposal of 11 November addresses dark patterns, prices, influencers and subscriptions. It is not yet applicable legislation.

Dark tablet with a blank screen and translucent circular panel
AI-generated image. This is not a documentary photograph.

The European Commission presented its proposal for a Digital Fairness Act on 11 November 2026, a regulation on unfair commercial practices intended to update consumer protection in digital markets. The text addresses dark patterns, addictive design, influencer advertising, personalised prices and contracts that are easy to start but difficult to cancel. This report of 16 November examines an initiative announced five days earlier, not an approval taking place today.

The first legal distinction matters as much as the list of measures: this is a proposal that the European Parliament and the Council will have to discuss. It does not justify announcing that all its prohibitions are already in force or attributing immediately enforceable new rights to consumers under this text. The Commission presented it alongside a simplification directive and a revision of cooperation between consumer authorities. These are related instruments, but they are not interchangeable.

From a directive to a regulation

The explanatory memorandum identifies the structural change: the draft would replace Directive 2005/29/EC on unfair commercial practices with a directly applicable regulation. Its stated purpose is to reduce fragmentation between national transpositions and facilitate a more uniform interpretation. This does not mean that Spanish consumer law suddenly disappears. It describes the structure that the Commission proposes for the future and its relationship with other parts of the package.

The draft retains the core prohibition of misleading and aggressive practices, but adds specific responses to digital conduct. Nor does it start from the assumption that all online activity is currently unregulated. The Commission's evaluation acknowledges that existing legislation remains necessary and relevant; at the same time, it identifies gaps and uncertainties when personalisation, interfaces or reward systems influence economic decisions at scale. That combination explains the reform better than describing a complete legal vacuum.

Dark patterns: the interface matters too

The explanation of Article 10 refers to the design and organisation of online interfaces that are likely to materially distort consumers' economic behaviour. The proposal provides for a general prohibition accompanied by a list of dark patterns considered unfair in all circumstances. According to the official press release, one example is falsely claiming that a product is almost sold out to pressure a purchase.

For advisers to a digital business, the subject of review would extend beyond the wording of general terms and conditions. The draft also looks at how a choice is offered and arranged. This is a consequence of the proposal's scope, not a statement that every persuasive commercial technique would be prohibited. Legitimate presentation of an offer should remain distinct from the specific situations that the legislature ultimately defines. The initial version may still change during the legislative process.

Influencers and personalisation: different problems

Article 11, as summarised in the memorandum, develops prominent identification of influencers' commercial communications and protection of minors' trust. In addition to creators' obligations, the draft envisages responsibilities for other participants in the commercial chain. The relevant issue is not that a post appears on a social network, but whether it is a commercial communication subject to identification and the other conditions envisaged.

Articles 12 and 13 address another issue: personalisation of advertising and prices through profiling. The proposal targets certain uses that may harm minors or vulnerable consumers and the use of special categories of data on the terms described in the text. This is not the same as banning every difference in price or declaring all targeted advertising unlawful. Data protection and consumer protection connect here, but the Commission presents the instrument as complementary to the GDPR and other digital legislation, rather than as their replacement.

Virtual currencies and mechanisms that encourage spending

Another group of provisions concerns spending-maximising practices. The memorandum places transparency of prices expressed in virtual currencies in Article 14 and variable reward systems and pay-to-win or pay-to-progress mechanisms in the following articles. The press release emphasises special protection for minors. For other consumers, the proposal includes possibilities to disable certain features.

Addictive design also receives separate treatment in Article 17. The official explanation concerns features intended, or reasonably foreseeable, to encourage compulsive or excessive use. The ability to disable them forms part of the proposed model. It would be incorrect to translate this group of provisions into a guarantee that a particular application no longer creates risks or into a clinical conclusion about its users. The draft proposes legal responses to commercial characteristics; it does not itself demonstrate the effects of each product.

Dynamic prices and virtual queues

According to the memorandum, Articles 18 and 19 address transparency of ticket prices when they increase dynamically and the use of virtual queues. The Commission explains that these queues would show the current price in real time and the highest possible price. This is a different problem from a virtual currency or a personalised rate: consumers need to understand the financial conditions while waiting to buy.

Precision about scope prevents excessive headlines. The press release does not announce a general end to dynamic pricing. It presents transparency requirements for certain situations. In contractual analysis, that distinction determines what information is requested from the client and which part of the purchase journey is examined. It also requires distinguishing between the displayed price, its possible evolution and the final decision to contract, rather than reducing everything to a single prohibition on prices.

Free trials, renewals and cancellation

The contractual provisions are particularly extensive. The explanation of Article 20 provides for a reminder and active acceptance of the conversion of a free trial into a paid contract. Articles 21 and 22 regulate reminders before automatic extensions of contracts of different durations. Article 23 envisages an online termination function, while Article 24 addresses withdrawal from distance contracts concluded through an interface.

These measures should not be confused. Preventing a trial from turning into a paid subscription without the envisaged acceptance is not the same as terminating an existing contract or exercising withdrawal rights. The Commission addresses all three stages because they create different obstacles. Legal review of a service would need to identify which is being analysed, what information accompanies the contract and how exit works, without assuming that the same button settles every right and obligation.

Article 25 introduces communication with a human being in online customer service after contracting, at the consumer's request and when other means are not effective; it excludes the investment services defined in that provision. Articles 26 and 27 concern automated systems used for contracting and pre-contractual information in transactions fully automated on both sides. The press release also mentions clear rights when consumers use an artificial intelligence agent to buy. This is not a general authorisation for any agent to contract without limits: the proposal itself includes consumers' ability to set the system's main parameters.

What to follow during the legislative process

The proposal should be read alongside strengthened consumer cooperation and the simplification directive, but each instrument has its own subject. The first practical question is which version is being used: the initial proposal of 11 November is not the eventual approved text. The second is which specific measure is being analysed. Grouping advertising, profiling, interface design and contract termination under a single label can conceal differences that matter to a client.

Related reading in other areas of digital regulation includes the articles on data transfers and BCRs, recruitment and artificial intelligence and the Google AdSense Opinion. These are not measures in the consumer package and do not replace its texts. For now, the package's conclusion is a defined and documented legislative agenda. It is not a new compliance date that can be set without the final text, nor a reason to stop reviewing the obligations that already apply to a business under the relevant legislation.

Sources

European Commission, proposal COM(2026) 1100 final and Digital Fairness Act page; press release IP/26/2407, dated 11 November 2026. Accessed: 16 November 2026.

Fuentes

  1. Source. Accessed 16 November 2026.
  2. Source. Accessed 16 November 2026.
  3. Source. Accessed 16 November 2026.

The specific data in this article come from the official sources cited.

Agente Lex Newsroom Redacción

Editorial team of AGENTE LEX. We produce analysis and news for the legal profession from public and official sources, which we link at the end of each article.

View profile and articles →