Law firm operations

The
High
Court
of
Extremadura
rules
there
is
no
employment
relationship
between
Glovo
and
its
riders:
the
Flex
model
rebutted
the
presumption

The
High
Court
of
Extremadura
annuls
a
TGSS
resolution
and
rules
that
Glovo's
Flex
model
rebutted
the
employment
presumption
for
riders.

AI-generated
illustration:
a
delivery
rider
with
a
thermal
backpack
next
to
a
bicycle
on
a
city
street
AI-generated
illustration.
Not
a
documentary
photograph.

The
Contentious-Administrative
Chamber
of
the
High
Court
of
Justice
of
Extremadura
has
upheld
the
appeal
filed
by
Glovo
against
a
resolution
of
the
General
Treasury
of
Social
Security
concerning
the
registration
and
deregistration
of
riders
in
the
Social
Security
system,
and
has
concluded
that
the
company
rebutted
the
employment
presumption
provided
for
digital
delivery
platforms.
The
judicial
news
published
by
the
Poder
Judicial
on
12
November
2026
summarizes
the
judgment:
the
so-called
Flex
model
incorporates
elements
that
allow
the
riders'
organizational
autonomy
to
be
appreciated.

The
appeal
was
processed
through
the
contentious-administrative
channel,
the
one
competent
to
review
Social
Security
resolutions
on
registration,
deregistration
and
contributions,
unlike
the
labor
channel,
through
which
individual
claims
for
recognition
of
the
employment
relationship
pass.
Upholding
the
appeal
renders
the
challenged
administrative
act
ineffective,
without
prejudice
to
what
the
cassation
appeal
may
decide.

The
court
annuls
both
the
resolution
of
the
TGSS
Provincial
Directorate
and
the
administrative
resolution
that
had
confirmed
it
on
appeal.
The
judgment
is
not
final
and
can
be
appealed
in
cassation
before
the
Third
Chamber
of
the
Supreme
Court.

The
five
Flex
model
elements
that
weighed
with
the
Chamber

According
to
the
Poder
Judicial
note,
the
Chamber
highlights
five
features
of
the
model
currently
used
by
the
company:
the
freedom
to
accept
or
reject
orders
without
penalty,
the
possibility
of
connecting
and
disconnecting
from
the
application
without
restrictions,
the
absence
of
exclusivity,
the
power
to
subcontract
or
designate
substitutes
and
the
non-existence
of
a
rating
or
activity
control
system
with
effects
on
the
allocation
of
services.

After
analyzing
the
documentation
and
reports
submitted
to
the
proceedings,
the
Chamber
considers
it
proven
that
these
characteristics
are
sufficiently
different
from
those
examined
in
previous
rulings
to
exclude,
in
this
specific
case,
the
existence
of
an
employment
relationship.
The
judgment
states
that
the
TGSS's
conclusions
relied
on
presumptions
that
have
been
rebutted
by
the
evidence
taken.

The
contrast
with
the
Supreme
Court's
2020
doctrine

The
judgment
does
not
ignore
the
existing
doctrine:
the
court
examines
the
evolution
of
case
law
on
digital
delivery
platforms
and
expressly
recalls
the
judgment
of
the
Fourth
Chamber
of
the
Supreme
Court
of
25
September
2020,
which
declared
the
employment
status
of
Glovo
riders.
The
key
to
the
Extremadura
ruling
lies
in
the
temporal
nuance:
the
dispute
focuses
on
determining
whether
the
modifications
subsequently
introduced
by
the
company
alter
the
elements
that
sustained
that
classification.

In
other
words,
the
Chamber
does
not
directly
contradict
the
2020
doctrine,
but
places
it
in
the
model
then
in
force
and
concludes
that
the
current
Flex
model,
with
the
evidence
available
in
this
file,
deserves
a
different
classification.
The
question
is
thus
raised
for
eventual
review
in
cassation,
since
the
Third
Chamber
of
the
Supreme
Court
is
the
channel
open
against
this
ruling.

How
the
five
elements
read
in
practice

Each
of
the
features
highlighted
by
the
Chamber
points
to
a
different
type
of
control.
The
freedom
to
accept
or
reject
orders
without
penalty
rules
out
subordination
in
the
provision
of
the
service:
the
rider
decides
which
assignments
to
take
on.
Connection
and
disconnection
without
restrictions
eliminates
the
imposed
schedule,
one
of
the
classic
indicators
of
dependence.
The
absence
of
exclusivity
allows
working
simultaneously
for
other
platforms
or
clients.
The
power
to
subcontract
or
designate
substitutes
breaks
the
personal
nature
of
the
provision,
another
traditional
indicator
of
working
for
another.
And
the
non-existence
of
a
rating
or
control
system
with
effects
on
the
allocation
of
services
rules
out
the
algorithm
operating
as
an
instrument
of
management.

None
of
these
elements,
in
isolation,
would
necessarily
be
decisive;
the
Chamber
assesses
them
together
and
against
the
evidence
in
the
file.
That
is
why
the
ruling
cannot
be
read
as
a
general
endorsement
of
any
delivery
model,
but
as
the
finding
that,
in
the
case
tried,
the
company
proved
those
features.

What
was
at
stake:
Social
Security
registrations
and
deregistrations

The
appeal
did
not
arise
from
an
individual
rider's
claim,
but
from
a
resolution
of
the
General
Treasury
of
Social
Security
on
the
registration
and
deregistration
of
riders
in
the
system.
This
is
the
usual
terrain
of
the
Labor
Inspectorate
and
the
TGSS
in
platform
matters:
if
an
employment
relationship
exists,
the
company
must
pay
contributions
for
the
riders;
if
not,
they
operate
as
self-employed.
The
annulment
of
the
resolution
renders
ineffective,
while
there
is
no
final
ruling
to
the
contrary,
the
registrations
and
deregistrations
the
TGSS
had
processed
under
the
employment
presumption.

The
employment
presumption
provided
for
digital
delivery
platforms
places
on
the
company
the
burden
of
proving
the
rider's
autonomy.
This
judgment
shows
that
the
presumption
can
be
rebutted
when
the
company
provides
sufficient
evidence
of
elements
of
organizational
autonomy,
although
each
case
will
depend
on
the
specific
operating
model
and
the
evidence
taken.

A
case
law
map
that
keeps
moving

The
classification
of
platform
riders
has
produced
rulings
in
different
directions
in
recent
years,
both
in
the
labor
and
the
contentious-administrative
channels,
precisely
because
operating
models
have
been
changing
since
the
first
judgments.
The
Extremadura
judgment
illustrates
that
dynamic:
the
company
adapts
its
model,
the
administration
presumes
employment
when
issuing
its
resolutions
and
the
courts
examine
case
by
case
whether
the
evidence
provided
rebuts
the
presumption.
For
law
firms
and
compliance
departments,
the
immediate
lesson
is
that
documentation
of
the
model
(order
acceptance
conditions,
allocation
systems,
substitution
policies)
becomes
decisive
evidence.

A
judgment
pending
cassation

For
the
affected
riders,
the
immediate
effect
of
the
ruling
is
the
annulment
of
the
registrations
and
deregistrations
the
TGSS
had
processed
under
the
presumption;
the
final
situation
will
depend
on
what,
where
appropriate,
the
cassation
appeal
decides.
For
the
company,
the
judgment
probatorily
validates
its
model
in
this
file,
without
preventing
future
inspection
actions
if
the
model
changes
again.

The
resolution
is
not
final.
The
cassation
appeal
before
the
Third
Chamber
of
the
Supreme
Court
remains
open,
so
the
final
word
on
the
Flex
model,
at
least
in
this
file,
has
not
yet
been
said.
In
the
meantime,
the
Extremadura
ruling
adds
to
a
diverse
case
law
map
on
delivery
platforms,
where
classification
depends
on
the
specific
features
of
the
model
applied
at
each
moment
and
in
each
territory.
In
our
opinion
piece
we
analyze
what
this
ruling
teaches
about
the
employment
presumption
and
its
rebuttal.

FAQ

What
has
the
High
Court
of
Extremadura
decided
about
Glovo?
That
the
company
rebutted
the
employment
presumption
of
its
riders
under
the
Flex
model,
and
it
has
annulled
the
TGSS
resolutions
on
Social
Security
registrations
and
deregistrations.

Is
the
judgment
final?
No.
It
can
be
appealed
in
cassation
before
the
Third
Chamber
of
the
Supreme
Court.

Does
it
contradict
the
2020
Supreme
Court
ruling?
The
Chamber
recalls
the
Fourth
Chamber
judgment
of
25
September
2020,
but
concludes
that
the
subsequent
modifications
of
the
model
alter
the
elements
that
sustained
that
classification.

Sources

Verified
on
14
November
2026
against
the
official
judicial
news
published
by
the
Poder
Judicial
on
12
November
2026.
The
note
does
not
indicate
the
number
or
date
of
the
judgment;
this
piece
is
limited
to
what
was
institutionally
communicated
and
could
not
be
contrasted
with
the
full
text
of
the
ruling.

Fuentes

  1. Source. Accessed 14 November 2026.

The specific data in this article come from the official sources cited.

Agente Lex Newsroom Redacción

Editorial team of AGENTE LEX. We produce analysis and news for the legal profession from public and official sources, which we link at the end of each article.

View profile and articles →