Opinion: a client who changes lawyer is not a lost asset
An editorial view on client freedom to change lawyer and continuity of service, based on Article 5 of Spain's Organic Law 5/2024.

When a client decides to work with another lawyer, a firm's language can turn that decision into an account loss, a client departure or business that somebody has taken away. Those expressions are understandable in a financial discussion. The problem begins when they displace the person who made the choice. This column argues that continuity in a professional relationship deserves an explanation based on the client's interests, rather than only the interests of those sharing the revenue.
The legal starting point is not new. Article 5 of Spain's Organic Law 5/2024 on the Right of Defence recognises the right to choose freely the lawyer providing assistance in a defence and to dispense with that lawyer's services, subject to any justified statutory exceptions. Its second paragraph requires appropriate measures, when a lawyer is replaced, to ensure that the incoming lawyer can access the information they consider appropriate for the defence. What follows is an editorial position based on that framework, not a ruling on a particular dispute.
This reflection continues the discussion of client trust and winning instructions, but moves to the point when the client decides to end the relationship, rather than how to win an engagement.
The relationship is not property
A firm may spend years serving an organisation. One partner may have opened the relationship and another maintained it. Recognising those contributions is a legitimate internal management question. Turning them into an entitlement over the client's wishes would be something different.
The distinction matters even where nobody formally challenges freedom of choice. If every departure is interpreted as betrayal, it becomes difficult to ask honestly why it happened. Needs may have changed, the client may prefer another team, or there may be dissatisfaction with the service. There is no need to assume which explanation applies to recognise that the decision cannot be understood solely from inside the firm.
The proposal is not to celebrate every departure or deny its cost. It is to avoid treating the financial impact as the only way to assess it. A firm must manage revenue; a person needing a defence must be able to decide whom to trust with it within the applicable legal framework.
Continuity should not depend on a dispute between partners
Debates about who originated an account and who deserves recognition can be complicated. The client should not become an instrument for settling them. If the team changes, the first concern should be explaining who will handle the matter and how continuity will be maintained, without asking the client to arbitrate an internal struggle.
This column does not propose ignoring contracts, professional duties or competition rules. Nor does it suggest that every action connected to a move between firms is lawful. It argues for an order of priorities: address any relevant disputes without losing sight of the represented person's decision and defence. An internal disagreement does not justify assuming that the client has no independent judgement.
Sharing a relationship does not mean choosing for the client
Having several people within a firm understand an account can help maintain service when someone is unavailable. It does not follow that the client must accept any replacement for their chosen contact. Internal organisation and external trust are different decisions, even when they are connected.
That is a reason to explain team changes rather than treat them as self-explanatory. A client may want continuity with one person, access to a particular practice or a different combination of professionals. This column cannot decide which preference should prevail in every situation. It can argue that understanding the preference is part of treating the client as a decision-maker, rather than as income assigned to a box.
The same principle applies when a partner changes firms. It should not be assumed in advance that every client will follow or that none may do so. Each situation requires attention to the relevant legal and professional limits. What this column challenges is the convenience of removing the client's choice through an assumption favourable to either firm.
Departure also reveals the quality of service
The law provides a specific reference point concerning access to information when a lawyer is replaced. The editorial conclusion is that the quality of a professional relationship can also be assessed when it ends, rather than only at the first meeting, when everyone wants the engagement to begin.
Explaining what remains outstanding and making the transition understandable are service objectives that can be considered without inventing a universal protocol. Appropriate measures will depend on the matter and the applicable rules. Article 5 does not itself provide a delivery timetable or a complete answer to every dispute over documents or fees.
That limit prevents a reasonable principle from becoming overbroad legal advice. This column does not suggest that outstanding obligations disappear when a client changes lawyer. It argues that discussing those obligations should not erase the person exercising the choice or turn their decision into a transfer between balance sheets.
A proper departure does not need to become a campaign
It may be tempting to turn a departure into another sales opportunity: one last presentation, an improvised offer or repeated calls to change the decision. This column proposes asking first whether the client wants that conversation. Not every departure is negotiable and not every refusal should be treated as an objection still waiting to be overcome.
That does not prevent a firm from clarifying a misunderstanding or correcting a mistake. It distinguishes a useful explanation from pressure that no longer serves the client's matter. This is a proposal about professional judgement, not a general prohibition on making offers or a description of how every law firm behaves.
The guide to moving from an initial consultation to an engagement concerns clarity at the start. This column argues for maintaining the same attention when the client makes the opposite decision.
Transparency should survive the decision to leave
Article 6 of the same law recognises information rights covering the status of the matter, relevant developments and decisions, general litigation costs and the procedure for setting professional fees. Those subjects help place the relationship around informed decisions. The provision is not being cited as though it created a specific departure form.
The editorial conclusion is narrower: clarity should not be reserved for people about to instruct the firm. If a firm explains the work well at the beginning but stops when the relationship's future is questioned, it is using information as an incentive to stay. This column rejects that understanding of service. Defending freedom of choice calls for consistency precisely when keeping the relationship is no longer assured.
Ask without demanding proof of loyalty
A firm may want to understand why a relationship is ending. The question will be more useful if it allows uncomfortable answers and is not framed as a demand for gratitude. Time spent deserves professional recognition; it does not purchase an indefinite obligation to stay.
The discussion about sharing origination credit concerns incentives within a firm. This reflection starts on the other side: the client is not the unit through which that allocation is settled. A relationship can be valuable to everyone while remaining one that the represented person is entitled to reconsider. Defending that distinction means taking the client's freedom seriously.