Industry news

The Supreme Court dismisses UGT-A's appeal and confirms the repayment of 8.8 million in training subsidies

The Supreme Court dismisses UGT Andalucía's appeal and confirms the repayment of 8,796,777 euros to the Junta over training subsidies for the unemployed.

AI-generated illustration: empty training classroom with chairs and folders on the desks
AI-generated illustration. Not a documentary photograph.

The Contentious-Administrative Chamber of the Supreme Court has dismissed the cassation appeal lodged by UGT Andalucía against the judgment ordering it to repay 8,796,777 euros to the Junta de Andalucía over alleged irregularities in subsidies for the training of unemployed people. The judgment, dated 13 October and released on Friday 6 November by Europa Press, republished by Iustel on 11 November, confirms that the trade union must pay just over 6.6 million euros as principal and more than 2.1 million in late-payment interest.

The ruling does not come alone. Barely a week earlier, in a judgment of 5 October, the high court itself had resolved an identical question, ordering UGT-A to repay 18,319,183.71 euros to the Andalusian government, also over training subsidies. The new decision expressly relies on that doctrine: "The coincidence between the question resolved in our judgment of 5 October and the one now raised determines that we follow the doctrine established in that resolution," the Chamber reasons.

The substance: the voluntary top-up is not paid with public funds

The legal controversy is specific and replicable to any recipient of aid: whether staff costs are eligible for subsidy to the extent that they exceed the legal minimums or those set in the applicable collective agreement. In other words, if an entity receiving a subsidy to deliver training pays its workers above the conventional minimum, can it charge that excess to public funds?

The High Court of Justice of Andalucía (TSJA) had answered no, in a formulation the Supreme Court now endorses: the "salary top-up voluntarily paid by the company, above what is provided in the collective agreement", cannot be considered an expense that "indisputably" responds to the nature of the subsidised activity nor an expense "strictly necessary" to carry it out.

The doctrine of the 5 October judgment

The high court retrieves the central reasoning of its earlier resolution and elevates it to directly applicable doctrine: "improvements agreed individually with workers must be borne with the beneficiary entity's own funds, since charging them to the subsidy would mean using public funds to finance these improvements."

And it adds a nuance that closes the door to the most common defence in these cases: the exclusion from public funding operates "even if they are not disproportionate according to market value". It does not matter, therefore, that the salary top-up is reasonable or matches what an equivalent professional earns in the sector; the criterion is not proportionality but the origin of the expense. Whatever exceeds the legal or conventional minimum is paid with own funds or not paid.

With that doctrine as premise, the Chamber declares that UGT-A's cassation appeal cannot succeed and rejects that remuneration exceeding the legal or conventional minimums can be declared eligible for subsidy.

The cost of time: what the interest reveals

One figure in the judgment deserves its own attention: against a principal of just over 6.6 million, the late-payment interest exceeds 2.1 million, close to a third of the principal. The figure is the accounting reflection of the duration of these proceedings, which tend to drag on for years between the repayment order, the administrative appeal, the first-instance judgment and cassation. For the appealing entity, late-payment interest turns each year of litigation into a substantial increase of the debt, a factor that should be weighed coolly before appealing.

It also illustrates why the definition of the eligible expense is litigated so intensely: what is at stake is not only the disputed item, but that item plus years of interest on thousands or millions of euros. When the disputed question is transversal (as here, where it affects the whole staff of the programme) the amount multiplies across every payroll of every edition of the call.

The distinction that decides the case: necessary versus voluntary

Behind the judicial formulation lies a technical distinction worth fixing. A subsidisable expense must, in essence, be a real expense, attributable to the funded activity and necessary to execute it. The trainer's salary within the conventional minimum passes that test without discussion: no trainer, no training. The voluntary top-up fails it, because the activity could have been carried out identically without it. That the salary improvement is lawful, reasonable or even convenient for the quality of the programme does not alter that conclusion: the question the Administration (and now the Supreme Court) asks is not whether the expense is good, but whether it is indispensable.

The 5 October judgment said it clearly and the 13 October one repeats it: financing those improvements with the subsidy amounts to "using public funds to finance these improvements", diverting money from its purpose. It is, at bottom, an application of the principle of purpose that governs the whole subsidy regime: public money funds the activity, not the beneficiary's pay policy.

A pattern repeating in the oversight of aid

The case belongs to a line of scrutiny of training subsidies in Andalucía that has been producing litigation for years, and the sum of the two October judgments (more than 27 million euros in repayments confirmed against a single organisation) gives an idea of the economic magnitude of the front. But the doctrine's significance overflows the specific case: any entity managing publicly funded programmes (foundations, associations, training companies, social entities) falls under the same criterion.

The practical lesson is one of documentary management and pay design. The beneficiary entity that wants to pay above the agreement may do so, but must be able to prove that the excess is borne with own funds and to separate it accounting-wise from the expenses charged to the aid. Mixing both sources in the same item is, in view of this case law, the shortest road to a repayment file.

Reading for advisers and subsidy managers

For professionals advising beneficiary entities, the judgment suggests three immediate preventions. First, reviewing the payrolls and pay agreements of staff assigned to subsidised programmes before the expense justification, not after. Second, documenting precisely the applicable agreement and the source of funds of any salary improvement. Third, assuming that the argument that the pay "is not disproportionate" has been neutralised: the Supreme Court has expressly discarded it twice in a month.

The control of subsidies is one of the most active fronts of Spanish contentious-administrative litigation, and the definition of the eligible expense is its permanent battlefield. On another contentious front of the high court, see the doctrine on defaulter lists and mass litigation. More analysis in the news section and in the coverage of proceedings and litigation.

What remains to be seen

The doctrine is settled, but its application will produce new chapters. It remains to be known whether the trade union exhausts other routes (a possible amparo appeal would require a constitutional significance hard to sustain on a question of expense qualification) and, above all, how many beneficiary entities of equivalent calls have similar pay structures pending review. If the criterion is applied with the same intensity to other files, the knock-on effect on the subsidised-training sector can be remarkable.

Frequently asked questions

How much must UGT Andalucía repay? 8,796,777 euros to the Junta de Andalucía: just over 6.6 million as principal and more than 2.1 million in late-payment interest, according to the Supreme Court judgment of 13 October.

Which expenses were considered non-eligible? Staff remuneration exceeding the legal or conventional minimums: the voluntary top-up paid by the entity above the collective agreement.

Does it matter that the top-up was reasonable or at market level? No. The Supreme Court expressly excludes public funding of voluntary pay improvements "even if they are not disproportionate according to market value": they must be borne with own funds.

Is this an isolated case? No. On 5 October the Supreme Court confirmed another repayment of 18,319,183.71 euros by UGT-A on the same question, and the 13 October judgment expressly applies that resolution's doctrine.

Sources

  • Europa Press, "El Supremo desestima el recurso de UGT-A y le obliga a pagar 8 millones por subvenciones para formacion" (Sevilla, 6 November; published on iustel.com on 11 November 2026), accessed 12 November 2026.

Fuentes

  1. Source. Accessed 12 November 2026.

The specific data in this article come from the official sources cited.

Agente Lex Newsroom Redacción

Editorial team of AGENTE LEX. We produce analysis and news for the legal profession from public and official sources, which we link at the end of each article.

View profile and articles →